Reasoning
Number - Which Deal Makes Sense?
Shop Offers
Shop 1: Buy 2 Get 1 Free
Shop 2: Up to 35% discount
Shop 3: 33â…“% off on all purchases
Your Task
work in a small group
Step 1- Understand the offers: As a group, discuss:
-
What does each offer mean mathematically?
-
What is guaranteed?
-
What is not guaranteed?
Step 2 - Decide and justify: For the basket of 3 items at €12 each:
-
Which shop gives the best deal?
-
Are any deals the same?
-
Which offer is least clear?
You must justify your decisions using numbers or calculations, words, a diagram or table (if helpful). A correct answer without explanation is not enough.
Step 3 - Challenge the advertising
Choose one statement below and explain whether it is always true, sometimes true, or never true:
​
-
“Buy 2 Get 1 Free is the same as 33â…“% off.”
-
“Up to 35% off means you will save 35%.”
-
“Percent discounts are always clearer than offers like Buy 2 Get 1 Free.”
Explain your reasoning clearly. Show how you know your answer would still make sense if the price changed.”
Step 4 - Be ready to defend your thinking
Be ready to explain why your reasoning works and how you would convince someone who disagrees.
